Evaluation Inflation

Agency SES rating systems were very generous in 2002 with more than 70 percent of executives receiving the highest grade their agencies awarded.

Agencies with three-level (pass-fail) rating systems
Department Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3
(passing)
Defense OSD 1 0 397
Education 0 0 63
HHS 0 1 307
HUD 0 0 64
Interior 1 0 184
Transportation 0 0 175
Agencies with four-level rating systems
Department Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3
(passing)
Grade 4
Energy 0 7 273 63
State 0 0 1 110
Agencies with five-level rating systems
Department Grade 1 Grade 2 Grade 3
(passing)
Grade 4 Grade 5
Agriculture 0 0 22 172 102
Commerce 0 0 6 36 173
Defense
(military agencies)
1 0 3 29 571
Justice 0 0 4 28 226
Labor 0 0 13 51 60
Treasury 0 0 53 165 207
VA 0 6 34 76 154

Source: Agency reports

NEXT STORY: Buck Private